- Bellator's Bane 2006
- Gold Cloth Scrap 3235
- Atlantean Explorer 2235
- Beach Comber 2833
- Broad Rigger 1944
- Bronze Archelon 1296
- Bronze Finius Pennant 1792
- Bronze Ghost Brig 1914
- Bronze Ghost Frigate 1567
- Bronze Ghost Sloop 1988
- Bronze Triketos 2100
- Color Guard 1740
- Deck Hand 3317
- Driftwood 2792
- Expert Rigger 492
- Featherweight of Sprinkles 2985
- Flag Bearer 2485
- Full Steam Ahead 3273
- Ghost Fish 1539
- Greedy Handful 3169
- Incredible Rigger 675
- Iron Coils 21
- Oaken Token of Rigging 470
- Old Glory 1298
- Pale Runner 2085
- Seafarer 3153
- Silver Ghost Sloop 1180
- Swordsman of Sprinkles 2899
- Waterlogged Spyglass 2860
- Broad Sailor 2250
- Sea Legs 2684
- Fifth Order of the Jolly Roger 1746
- First Order of the Jolly Roger 2666
- Fourth Order of the Jolly Roger 1886
- Second Order of the Jolly Roger 2276
- Seventh Order of the Jolly Roger 1533
- Sixth Order of the Jolly Roger 1631
- Third Order of the Jolly Roger 2096
- Coat of Arms 1984
- Hoard Burglar 897
- Bronze-bound Atlas 1838
- Silver Embossed Atlas 1345
- Eighth Order of the Jolly Roger 1417
- Ink Splotch 653
- One-eyed Jack 994
- Weathered Helm 702
- Adept Swordsman of Sprinkles 2211
- Adept Swordsman of Strikes 1877
- Astral Anchor 1837
- Broad Bilger 2567
- Broad Carpenter 2227
- Broad Gunner 1987
- Broad Navigator 1659
- Broad Patcher 1508
- Broad Poker Player 1731
- Broad Treasure Hauler 1702
- Bronze Citadel 1941
- Bronze Cutter 1666
- Bronze Dhow 1589
- Bronze Fanchuan 1599
- Bronze Longship 1061
- Bronze Merchant Galleon 1722
- Bronze Seal of Madness 960
- Bronze Sloop 1473
- Bronze Spoon 1748
- Bronze War Frigate 627
- Bronze Xebec 1910
- Emerald Blackjack 2817
- Fresh Zombie Hand 1713
- Gold Tooth 2961
- Gold Tooth n' Patch 2264
- Greedy Heap 1782
- Greedy Lunger 1304
- Greedy Pile 2735
- Greedy Poker 2618
- Hijacked Jewelry 1437
- Imperial Private Insignia 1633
- Incredible Treasure Hauler 1877
- Jack-Tar 1973
- Longship Vanquisher 2035
- Mariner 1661
- Middleweight of Sprinkles 2251
- Mug o' Blood 2463
- Pilfered Goods 1118
- Ruby Gaff 1715
- Sandbar Skipper 1519
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2020 1227
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2018 256
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2019 345
- Silver Crab 2106
- Skeleton Crew 1999
- Skellie Hunter 2148
- Snowbeard Victorious 2 50
- Splintered Axes 2035
- Stomped Shako 1175
- Sunken Ship's Bell 1532
- Swordsman of Strikes 2663
- Zombie Hunter 1941
- Atlantean Tablet 1861
- Briny Mask 1324
- Cultist Crusher 1566
- Cursed Banner 1673
- Vargas Vanquisher 1506
- Bronze Sigil 745
- Hasty Sketch 1737
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2020 502
- Incredible Gunner 1190
- Flailing Flan 693
- Kraken Skulls 533
- Cursed Forager 1282
- Frenetic Forager 1163
- Bronze Gorgonyx 1313
- Silver Citadel 998
- Silver Triketos 1107
- Bronze Ship Graveyard 1390
- Blademaster of Sprinkles 585
- Elite Swordsman of Sprinkles 1311
- Elite Swordsman of Strikes 963
- Featherweight of Strikes 1230
- Heavyweight of Sprinkles 1257
- Oaken Token of Bilge 738
- Oaken Token of Sails 581
- Seal of Bilge 555
- Seal of Rigging 394
- Seal of Sails 801
- Incredible Bilger 1159
- Incredible Carpenter 1292
- Incredible Distiller 206
- Incredible Forager 1309
- Incredible Navigator 532
- Incredible Sailor 1298
- Incredible Shipwright 587
- Amethyst Chain n' Pin 365
- Black Diamond Rumbler 182
- Finders Keepers Losers Weepers 729
- Greedy Barrager 160
- Greedy Hoard 381
- Greedy Striker 408
- Greedy Trove 939
- Sapphire Brass Knuckles 680
- Brotherhood of the Bronze Pineapple 351
- Chalice of Blood 1089
- Bronze Death's Head 770
- Bronze Hourglass 806
- Bronze Jaws 1167
- Silver Finius Pennant 268
- Cannon of the Deep 509
- Detailed Rendering 282
- Oyster 554
- Reef Raider 484
- Shattered Swords 1007
- Silver Pickaxe 480
- Bronze Baghlah 731
- Bronze Grand Frigate 1628
- Bronze Junk 751
- Bronze Merchant Brig 885
- Bronze War Brig 1168
- Gold Merchant Galleon 96
- Gold Xebec 142
- Silver Fanchuan 562
- Silver Grand Frigate 653
- Silver Merchant Galleon 731
- Silver War Brig 330
- Silver Xebec 856
- Broad Battle Navigator 1318
- Broad Blacksmith 1194
- Broad Distiller 679
- Broad Forager 1439
- Broad Shipwright 1342
- Broad Swordfighter 1353
- Expert Bilger 807
- Expert Carpenter 762
- Expert Navigator 516
- Expert Sailor 793
- An Eye for Grain 1078
- Bejeweled Crab 560
- Celestial Sloop 568
- Golden Crab 1174
- Heavenly Hook 929
- Radiant Jolly Roger 169
- Savvy Sailor 628
- Silver Cannon 1205
- Bone Head 1910
- Flotilla Fighter 466
- Flotilla Freebooter 1131
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2020 811
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2020 760
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2020 134
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2014 151
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2015 82
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2020 530
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2020 283
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2020 326
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2020 330
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2020 222
- Gilded Atlas 808
- Initialed Ingot 1219
- Stamped Ingot 1606
- Kraken Bait 55
- Van Helsing's Bronze Hammer 215
- Bone Brothers 1138
- Corpse Corps 438
- Inner Skelly 1063
- Silver Ghost Brig 570
- Incredible Weaver 415
- Expert Distiller 130
- Silver Sloop 608
- Broad Weaver 624
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2014 138
- Sublime Distiller 28
- Golden Sandals of Hermes 55
- Sage Banner 385
- Skellie Slayer 1125
- Zombie Slayer 927
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2014 182
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2012 219
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2017 214
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2016 201
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2014 98
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2016 173
- Bronze Eye of Flame 768
- Crumpled Helm 304
- X Marks the Spot 389
- Incredible Blacksmith 756
- Golden Citadel 479
- Seal of Carpentry 430
- Banana on the Savannah 334
- Beach Curiosity 347
- Golden Ghost Sloop 461
- Haunted Chest 779
- Monogrammed Ingot 869
- Oaken Token of Carpentry 584
- Plum Chewin' Gum 277
- Bronze Gauntlet 408
- Golden Gauntlet 75
- Silver Gauntlet 178
- Soggy Chest 838
- Bronzed Zombie Hand 175
- Head Honcho 206
- Head Hunter 858
- Preserved Zombie Hand 749
- Skellies' Bane 323
- Werewolf Hunter 750
- Zombies' Bane 267
- First Gold 1180
- Lucy's Silver Cameo 218
- Map and Brew 440
- Jade Monkey 775
- Ultimate Poker Player 741
- Hair of the Dog 262
- Renfield's Knickers 244
- Broad Alchemist 752
- Bronze Valkyrie Helm 638
- Oaken Token of Patching 347
- Seal of Patching 277
- Fencer 493
- The Count's Golden Medallion 276
- Thirteenth Order of the Jolly Roger 545
- Anchored by Chocolate 123
- Ancient Sealing Tablet 121
- Banana Bandana on Nana 101
- Banana Cabana 133
- Banana Hand 51
- Banana-ramma 72
- Barfly 192
- Bejeweled Tourney Board 46
- Blast Monkey 84
- Bloomin' Skull 47
- Blossoming Banner 51
- Broad Drinker 253
- Broad Hearts Player 575
- Broad Rumbler 493
- Broad Spades Player 439
- Broad Treasure Drop Player 317
- Bronze Badge 71
- Bronzed Tourney Board 162
- Budding Blade 49
- Candy Corn 237
- Ceremonial Crystal Seal 116
- Choco Skull 75
- Chunk o' Obsidian 72
- Corsair's Chianti 112
- Crimson Banner 189
- Crimson Bill's Plume 159
- Crimson and Jade Statuette 61
- Daffodil 330
- Eleventh Order of the Jolly Roger 951
- Enlightened Eradicator 878
- Expert Poker Player 548
- Eye of the Zombie 24
- Fall n' Crossbones 63
- Fish-gobbler's Golden Guilder 117
- Fist Full o' Treats 177
- Frozen Tricorne 84
- Gilded Sanguinary Chalice 41
- Glittering Gold 48
- Grape Ape Wine 66
- Greyghost's Treasure 156
- Greyghost's Treasure Map 149
- Hearty Harvest 49
- Hot Co-ho-ho-coa 69
- Hunter Banner 349
- Ice Chest 54
- Jinxed Idol 446
- Loose Seal 101
- Ninth Order of the Jolly Roger 1262
- Penguin Fetish 104
- Penguin Phaseal Statue 127
- Pirate Playset 80
- Plum Crazy 68
- Plum Tuckered Out 66
- Plum in the Sun 59
- Plum the Depths 131
- Reindeer Feed 22
- Rites of Spring 51
- Rope Seal 69
- Scrapper 302
- Seal Fetish 119
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2017 272
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2011 226
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2015 189
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2017 204
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2018 213
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2015 162
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2018 184
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2015 168
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2017 179
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2018 140
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2018 81
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2012 207
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2014 154
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2013 176
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2015 90
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2015 75
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2018 65
- Secondary Spheniscus 46
- Silver Cannon Ball 45
- Sky-shark Glider 83
- Snowflake o' Piracy 53
- Soggy Boot 394
- Spring Wheel 188
- Sterling Tourney Board 70
- Stone Symbol 97
- Tenth Order of the Jolly Roger 1102
- Tufted Wolf-Wear 567
- Twelfth Order of the Jolly Roger 780
- Ultimate Treasure Hauler 243
- Victory Banner 305
- Vinyarrrd Fresh 62
- X'Ukara Statue 118
- Ye Dread Sprout 80
- Yeti's Soiled Apron 45
- Yohoho and a Jug o' Merlot 45
- Adorominable Snow Man 117
- Incredible Alchemist 289
- Scale Model 59
- Prize Holiday Goose 87
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2009 209
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2009 46
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2010 106
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2012 178
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2009 185
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2009 86
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2009 61
- Valuable Chest 290
- Eerie Chest 213
- Rolling Pin of the Frost Giants 46
- Seasoned Old Salt 338
- Shining Silver 59
- Shiny Shapeshifter 129
- Silver Cutter 622
- Silver Daybed 31
- Silver Death's Head 98
- Silver Eye of Flame 78
- Silver Hourglass 78
- Silver Seal of Madness 103
- Silver Valkyrie Helm 76
- #1 Poker Player 89
- Gilded Harpoons 47
- Glacial Gold 52
- Golden Trailblazer 42
- Golden Triketos 467
- Lunch with Zeus 60
- Sublime Sailor 229
- Ye Golden Chained Saw 52
- Imperial Captain Insignia 158
- Imperial Corporal Insignia 601
- One-Eyed Maple 57
- Werewolf Slayer 195
- Hexed Forager 702
- Aye Think I Can, Aye Think I Can 161
- Ornamental Cabin Elf 35
- Gunwhale 97
- Octo Bomber 102
- Tattered Flag 345
- Deviled Eggs 459
- Hoard Thief 517
- Middleweight of Strikes 545
- Champion of Sprinkles 539
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2020 371
- Pillars of Sails 223
- Father Frost's Muffin Tray 42
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2015 118
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2015 162
- Golden Cannon 363
- Ultimate Gunner 200
- Choc Full o' Loot 288
- Expert Gunner 446
- Fourteenth Order of the Jolly Roger 295
- Primary Pygoscelis 60
- Revered Sailor 116
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2014 219
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2011 145
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2013 227
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2019 331
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2014 106
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2015 84
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2016 91
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2019 95
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2020 302
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2015 265
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2019 242
- Expert Rumbler 46
- Expert Swordfighter 274
- Expert Treasure Hauler 209
- Silver Archelon 132
- Silver Gorgonyx 130
- Golden Ghost Brig 93
- Silver Ghost Frigate 103
- Bribery Box 209
- Palm Grease 216
- Diamond Candy Cane 73
- Flame of Silver Spirit 56
- Toy Soldier Scout 97
- Ye Royal Bilge Bucket 39
- Laurels of Victory 50
- Sleigh Captain 27
- Undead Nunchaku 22
- Misleadingly Mundane Monster 21
- Krak Head 322
- Eggcellent Chocolate Surprise 57
- Icy Blades 57
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2013 119
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2013 91
- Winged Shoes 185
- Bronzed Zombie Foot 35
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2017 139
- Cratchit's Raise 137
- Golden Elf Hat 29
- Pocket Full o' Goodies 150
- Ye Jolly Taffy 241
- Silver Dhow 559
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2014 103
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2020 115
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2014 51
- Beach Plum 66
- Plumscreen Lotion 48
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2012 179
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2016 81
- Snowbeard Victorious 51
- Expert Patcher 243
- Ghost Gem 219
- Gilded Eternal Hourglass 65
- Silver War Frigate 65
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2016 209
- Captain's Case 353
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2019 267
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2010 126
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2011 192
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2010 172
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2013 155
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2016 144
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2010 173
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2010 141
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2010 180
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2011 131
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2013 137
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2010 97
- Banana Bandana Bonanza 56
- Choco Shako 61
- Craftsman's Bronze Chisel 58
- Green Spring 50
- Payoff Purse 160
- Plum Rum 61
- Vampiric Signet Ring 37
- Whinin' Cheese 42
- Ultimate Carpenter 189
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2019 285
- Silvered Skellie Bone 47
- Hard Boiled 286
- Rorschach 305
- Laurels of Icy Victory 36
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2010 159
- Tertiary Tereingaornis 56
- Expert Alchemist 101
- Pillars of Carpentry 85
- Sublime Carpenter 186
- Sublime Navigator 79
- Ultimate Navigator 95
- Blademaster of Strikes 309
- Ultimate Swordfighter 213
- Battered Shield 57
- Roly Poly Fish Bucket 42
- Sealed the Deal 139
- Sublime Patcher 28
- Token of Thread 12
- Expert Forager 269
- Hoard Raider 161
- Growling Golden Gore-spiller 58
- Heavyweight of Strikes 137
- Homunculus Humbler 273
- Silver Junk 108
- Silver Longship 218
- Flame of Bronze Resolve 44
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2016 87
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2019 133
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2016 52
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2019 81
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2016 166
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2019 278
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2017 98
- Seal o' Piracy: July 2017 128
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2016 95
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2017 92
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2016 93
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2017 178
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2018 194
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2019 120
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2016 124
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2017 86
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2017 41
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2016 40
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2017 56
- Silver Mitten 21
- Slice o' Ice 154
- Slithery Keepsake 59
- Spring Training 68
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2012 285
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2011 92
- Bushel of Reindeer Apples 21
- Old Man Winter's Cookie Cutters 52
- Emperor's Vintage 48
- Pirate Plumder 59
- Ultimate Forager 133
- Ultimate Sailor 178
- Eldritch Plunder 140
- Ghost's Purse 224
- Silver Ship Graveyard 71
- Bone Lute 24
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2016 70
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2012 180
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2011 111
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2014 81
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2010 210
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2011 191
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2010 138
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2011 131
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2012 119
- Exalted Carpenter 29
- Expert Battle Navigator 169
- Expert Blacksmith 114
- Revered Carpenter 82
- Revered Navigator 21
- Enlightened Forager 207
- Assembled Model Frigate 151
- Flame of Gilded Courage 41
- Frenzy Rising 40
- Gilded Spirit Board 84
- Realistic Rocking Pony 160
- Shivering Silver 51
- Snarling Silver Scent-stalker 53
- Snowbeard Avenger 92
- Torch and Trident 36
- Toy Collection 122
- Unwrapped Imperial Soldier 157
- Ye Olde Harvest Moon 54
- Gold Sloop 131
- Bootlicker's Banner 86
- Bowl of Blood 151
- Grain Adept 93
- Sailing Rations Kit 105
- Silver Explorer 43
- Survival Supply Kit 100
- Hardwood Pathfinder 33
- #1 Carpenter 33
- Fuzzy Freebooter 159
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2018 130
- Revered Bilger 67
- Sublime Bilger 162
- Grain Guru 25
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2019 95
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2017 43
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2017 119
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2018 131
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2019 183
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2018 93
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2019 125
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2020 186
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2018 111
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2017 78
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2019 35
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2017 62
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2018 58
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2019 62
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2020 115
- Diamond Crab 186
- Ectoplasm and Cheese on Rye 34
- Revenant Rock Receptacle 46
- Spirit Stone Sampler 122
- Herring Bone Haypenny 60
- Sealperial Thumper 137
- Fezziwig's Punch Bowl 71
- Gilded Werewolf Claw 44
- Token of Wood 22
- Gold Grand Frigate 121
- Greedy Sword Stormer 36
- Pillars of Rigging 57
- #1 Gunner 32
- #1 Sword Fighter 32
- #1 Treasure Hauler 38
- Bejeweled Cannon 26
- Green Grog 91
- #1 Spades Player 15
- Ultimate Spades Player 56
- Silver Clattering Chain 66
- Silver Jaws 116
- Silver Sigil 72
- Expert Hearts Player 141
- Expert Spades Player 124
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2015 73
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2015 66
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2015 79
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2018 97
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2014 44
- Revered Rigger 45
- Sublime Forager 29
- Sublime Rigger 104
- Exalted Rigger 16
- Expert Shipwright 193
- Bronze Self-writing Quill 47
- Silver Baghlah 113
- Silver Merchant Brig 178
- Gold Cutter 78
- Gold Dhow 63
- Gold Fanchuan 62
- Gold War Brig 30
- Green Jack 56
- Lost Figurehead 70
- Island Hopper 78
- Seal o' Piracy: August 2013 87
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2018 62
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2015 123
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2014 84
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2013 77
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2014 50
- Bashed Shield 61
- Boots of Bilging 51
- Fragment of Underdone Potato 76
- Snowy Swashbuckler 51
- Banana King Figurine 42
- Choklit Chomper 64
- Fudgefoot Print 47
- Dennis 56
- Bronze Booties 25
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2013 124
- Boom! Headshot 181
- Extra Extra Rare Steak 32
- Pillars of Bilge 181
- #1 Hearts Player 15
- Ultimate Hearts Player 39
- Sublime Hearts Player 34
- Sublime Spades Player 36
- Sack of Flight Powder 22
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2013 98
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2013 207
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2013 54
- Battered Hat 145
- Rope Knot 36
- Seal o' Piracy: May 2010 163
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2010 96
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2016 34
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2016 49
- Ultimate Bilger 185
- Ultimate Blacksmith 79
- Ultimate Rigger 134
- Revered Poker Player 28
- Sublime Poker Player 91
- Steel Seal 33
- Laurels of Frostbite 44
- Flotilla Fanatic 83
- Sterling Sigil 25
- Expert Weaver 32
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2009 96
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2010 178
- Seal o' Piracy: January 2012 125
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2011 143
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2012 104
- Master's Golden Hammer 59
- Chum Bucket 23
- Diamond Vampire Fangs 76
- Gold Digger 43
- Hammer and Sharpened Pegleg 62
- Hit the Showers 43
- Laurel of Poison Ivy 48
- Masterful Sea Dog 86
- Proto-diamond 19
- Seal o' Piracy: March 2013 93
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2013 85
- Subantarctic Silver Dollar 72
- Toy Bounty 74
- Ultimate Battle Navigator 96
- Cutter Hunter 30
- Journeyman's Silver Saw 55
- Merchant Brig Hunter 19
- Merchant Galleon Hunter 15
- Toady's Treasure Trove 94
- Ultimate Patcher 86
- Ultimate Weaver 49
- Pillars of Patching 32
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2012 129
- Seal o' Piracy: December 2011 102
- Seal o' Piracy: February 2011 95
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2010 104
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2011 76
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2011 61
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2012 65
- Incredible Patcher 116
- Bronze Javelin of Procris 48
- Dormant Beast 32
- Ghostly Brass Door Knocker 87
- Embers of Defeat 39
- Glittering Chest 55
- Sublime Gunner 73
- Abandoned Crutch 71
- Orca Repellent 41
- Bold Bronze 59
- Imperial Eye Patch 41
- Outdated Calendarrr 47
- Nose-glow Wax 33
- Bronze Nocturne 41
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2019 61
- Boreal Bronze 42
- Fifteenth Order of the Jolly Roger 54
- Ultimate Drinker 44
- Gilded Loup Garou 11
- Werewolf's Bane 23
- Book of Zombie 32
- Sanctified Bilge Water 32
- Snow Maiden's Spatulas 42
- The Call of the Wild 33
- Wax Fangs 31
- Ultimate Rumbler 71
- #1 Drinker 14
- Iron Tackle 40
- Jar of Ectoplasmic Preserves 55
- Silver Discus of Heracles 43
- Tinted Spectacles 34
- Seal of the Tackle 36
- Water Marble 32
- Wind Marble 116
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2011 54
- Army of Darkness 128
- Drudge's Rejected Toy Parts 46
- Patchy Provisions 87
- Respectable Replenishment 41
- Ship Materials Kit 103
- Ye Olde Weevily Biscuit 50
- Sublime Shipwright 24
- Rogue Vintage 45
- Yococoa Cake 46
- Bronze Haunted Locket 65
- Flame of Ultimate Victory 40
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2014 78
- Banana Blade 44
- Expert Drinker 18
- Skull n' Crosscones 50
- Hoard Bandit 58
- Seal of Ink 65
- Token of Rope 19
- Token of the Sheets 3
- Seal o' Piracy: April 2018 62
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2013 44
- Handful o' Toys 57
- Pea Shooter 109
- Ultimate Shipwright 90
- A Good Haul 52
- Pile o' Presents 38
- Chocolate Harvest 48
- Exalted Poker Player 8
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2012 102
- Wooden Stair 26
- Silver Spyglass 42
- Seal o' Piracy: September 2012 105
- Humble Bundle 68
- Iron Hammer 12
- Seal o' Piracy: June 2011 106
- Seal o' Piracy: November 2012 91
- Here comes ye Cavalry 162
- Exalted Hearts Player 7
- Exalted Spades Player 5
- Revered Hearts Player 17
- Revered Spades Player 16
- Big Bad Bronze Beastie 32
- Golden Ghost Frigate 9
- Chilling Chest 24
- Sublime Treasure Hauler 8
- #1 Battle Navigator 24
- Gold Eye of Flame 26
- Gold Finius Pennant 65
- Gold Jaws 29
- Gold Sigil 20
- Hijacked Load 43
- Iron Pump 48
- Bone-ana Split 50
- Gold Death's Head 28
- Gold Hourglass 24
- Gold Seal of Madness 25
- Gold Valkyrie Helm 20
- Gilded Seal 19
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2014 39
- Seal o' Piracy: October 2014 64
- Silvered Whispering Portrait 49
- #1 Navigator 26
- #1 Sailor 28
- Ultimate Pirate 12
- Spires of the Tackle 10
- Towers of Wind 23
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2010 73
- Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2011 63
- Extensive Equipage 19
- Rum Pum Pum Rum 107
- Supreme Stockpile 11
- Exalted Sailor 54
- Seal o' Piracy: 2017 17
- Seal o' Piracy: 2018 21
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2018 30
- Seal o' Piracy: 2019 24
- #1 Alchemist 14
- #1 Bilger 28
- #1 Blacksmith 15
- #1 Distiller 15
- #1 Forager 23
- #1 Patcher 30
- #1 Rigger 28
- #1 Shipwright 21
- Ultimate Alchemist 43
- Ultimate Crafter 6
- Ultimate Distiller 33
- Expert Treasure Drop Player 24
- Sublime Swordfighter 45
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2015 47
- Snow-ho-ho and a Bottle of Rum! 54
- Jolly Shamrocks 45
- Bronze Adventurer 53
- Fuzzy Slippers 36
- Swinging Banana 56
- Jolly Green Roger 50
- Plum-bob Quadrant 60
- Seal o' Piracy: 2009 36
- Seal o' Piracy: 2010 31
- Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2010 57
- Booty-filled Stocking 32
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2013 42
- Toppled Crown 15
- Imperial Colonel Insignia 23
- Choctopus 41
- Frosted Frigate 42
- Boogeyman's Bounty 34
- #1 Treasure Drop Player 6
- Dutch Tulip 5
- Ultimate Carouser 4
- Ultimate Treasure Drop Player 40
- Seal of the Spool 8
- Champion of Strikes 20
- Thread Ball 37
- Bountiful Treat Bowl 4
- Bucket o' Loot 43
- Gathering o' Gifts 28
- Towers of Water 6
- Overstuffed Pillowcase 4
- Seal o' Piracy: 2012 31
- Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2012 49
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2012 55
- Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2015 31
- Ghost King's Hoard 4
- Seal of the Sheets 4
- Transcendent Sailor 16
- Sublime Rumbler 5
- Pirate's Press 58
- Jack Frost's Egg Blizzarder 43
- Seal of the Pump 7
- Token of Water 29
- Zombie Chowder 18
- Society of the Silver Coconut 25
- Gold War Frigate 2
- Apprentice's Stuffing and Paints 43
- Ice Skullpture 42
- Seal o' Piracy: 2011 29
- Pinot Yarrr 41
- Sublime Alchemist 12
- Revered Alchemist 8
- Sublime Treasure Drop Player 2
- Antediluvian Conch 6
- Golden Archelon 11
- Golden Gorgonyx 8
- Ship in a Bottle 35
- Token of Wind 23
- Horn of Plunder 46
- Exalted Bilger 20
- Token of the Pump 4
- Transcendent Bilger 3
- Savage Majesty 29
- Spectre Snacks 14
- Ye Jolly Campfire 2
- Seal o' Piracy: 2016 14
- Quinquennial Seal o' Piracy 20
- Seal o' Piracy: 2015 24
- Seal o' Piracy: 2014 26
- Seal o' Piracy: 2013 24
- Boastful Barrel 32
- Cracking Crates 13
- Snowbeard's Sleigh 6
- Revered Swordfighter 13
- Revered Distiller 12
- Exalted Shipwright 5
- Revered Shipwright 7
- Sublime Battle Navigator 11
- Exalted Gunner 3
- Revered Gunner 16
- Gold Baghlah 7
- Gold Merchant Brig 15
- Transcendent Swordfighter 2
- Exalted Swordfighter 4
- Santa's Sack 18
- Diamond Grand Frigate 6
- Towers of Wood 3
- Revered Patcher 7
- Sublime Blacksmith 7
- Diamond Sloop 9
- Revered Forager 5
- Golden Spade 8
- Diamond Cutter 2
- Diamond Dhow 2
- Diamond Fanchuan 2
- Gold Longship 13
- Spires of the Hammer 2
- Seal of the Hammer 5
- #1 Rumbler 9
- Skelly Grimoire 23
- #1 Weaver 11
- Sublime Weaver 3
- Plenty o' Packages 14
- Exalted Distiller 4
- Barrel of Bugaboo Baubles 11
- Exalted Navigator 6
- Bradford Starfish 1
- Pink Heart 2
- Diamond Merchant Galleon 6
- Token of the Hammer 4
- Transcendent Poker Player 1
- Merchant Brig Bane 2
- Cutter Slayer 6
- Merchant Brig Slayer 3
- Merchant Galleon Slayer 3
- Diamond Xebec 4
- Unearthly Chest 3
- Revered Treasure Hauler 2
- Golden Glyph 9
- Transcendent Carpenter 5
- Exalted Patcher 1
- Boatload o' Fun 4
- Gold Junk 6
- Exalted Alchemist 2
- Revered Weaver 1
- Token of the Tackle 2
- Transcendent Distiller 1
- Revered Battle Navigator 1
- Towers of Thread 4
- Exalted Blacksmith 1
- Revered Blacksmith 1
- Order of the Golden Banana 1
- Ultimate of Ultimates 1
- Overflowing Chest 2
- Transcendent Rigger 2
- Transcendent Shipwright 1
- Dread Masterpiece 5
- Cutter Bane 2
- Merchant Galleon Bane 1
- Diamond Merchant Brig 2
- Transcendent Navigator 1
- Spires of the Spool 1
- Gilded Egg 2
- Transcendent Spades Player 1
- Wizard of Woodgrain 1
- Exalted Rumbler 2
- Revered Rumbler 2
- Bodegraven Wheel O' Cheese 1
- Delftware Cannon 1
- Diamond Cannon 2